Top 10 Licensed Plumbers in Bargersville Indiana

Updated on September 1, 2021

Licensed Plumbers Bargersville Indiana

Sooner or later, every homeowner winds up with a plumbing problem they can’t address on their own. It may be something as simple as a busted garbage disposal. Or, it may be something as serious as a broken hot water heater, a natural gas leak, or a sump pump that’s malfunctioning. Regardless, it’s important to find a local plumbing business that can offer you fast, affordable service and do good, high-quality work.

Table of Contents

For homeowners who live in Bargersville, Indiana, there are a plethora of plumbing companies to choose from. The question is, how do you know which one is most reputable? How do you know which plumber will do the best work and offer the best value? Here are a few general tips and guidelines, along with our recommendations for 10 excellent plumbers in the Bargersville area.

Looking for the Best Bargersville Plumbers

As you begin your search for the best plumbing company, there are a few general tips you can follow.

  • Ask for personal recommendations. Personal recommendations can go a long way toward finding a skilled plumber who will offer you friendly service and affordable rates. Ask around in your neighborhood, at work, at church, at the gym, or wherever else you spend time. See if anyone in your community has recently hired a plumber, and if so, what they thought of the experience.
  • Read online reviews. Whether or not you obtain a good personal recommendation, always take some time to vet local plumbing services on Google. Online reviews may not be infallible, and no one review should skew your decision, but the overall consensus should be pretty revealing. For example, if a local plumber gets 100 reviews and 98 of them are five-star raves, that should tell you something. (And of course, the same goes for plumbers whose reviews are lackluster across the board.)
  • Shop around. Sometimes, you may have a real plumbing emergency, something that requires you to find a plumbing business ASAP. But if you have the luxury of time, you might as well call three or four different plumbers and compare them. Specifically consider the time frames each plumber gives you, the prices you are quoted, and the quality of their customer service.

With these basic tips, you should be well on your way toward finding a qualified plumber serving the Bargersville area.

What to Look for in a Plumbing Business

Not all plumbing companies are worth your time and your trust. The question is, what are some of the factors that separate the good plumbers from those who are sub-par? Here are a few of the things you should always look for when selecting plumbing services.

Customer Service

First and foremost, make sure you seek plumbing companies that actually act like they want to earn your business. You deserve a plumber who will be helpful, respectful, and kind. If you talk to a plumber or to a service representative who does not treat you well, that’s a good reason to continue your search elsewhere.


Something else you should always look for is a valid plumbing license. Most plumbers will list their license number on their website, but if you don’t see it, ask for it over the phone. We urge against hiring unlicensed plumbers. We’ll explain why in just a moment.

Pricing Transparency

Seek plumbers who will be honest and upfront about how much the job is going to cost. The last thing you want is to hire someone to repair your water heater, only to have a bunch of surprise costs and hidden fees sprung on you at the last minute. If a plumber won’t answer basic questions about price, or if they refuse to offer a written estimate, that’s typically a red flag.

Range of Services

Different homeowners are going to have different plumbing problems, so always verify that the plumber in question can handle your particular issue. Specifically double-check their experience with less common plumbing needs, such as installation of tankless water heaters. Also keep in mind that most plumbers are not licensed to do HVAC or furnace repair work, so if that’s what you need, make sure you ask for it.

Emergency Availability

Do you need to call a plumber beyond normal business hours? Be sure that you verify their emergency availability. It doesn’t hurt to ask about any extra fees you’ll pay for their after-hours response.

Local Reputation

Above all, make sure you find a local plumbing company that is well-regarded within the Bargersville community. Online reviews help, as do affiliations with the Better Business Bureau or the local Chamber of Commerce. Years of experience can also be a meaningful metric; businesses that have lasted for decades tend to be fairly solid.

Why Hire a Licensed Plumber?

We mentioned above how important it is to find a plumber with a valid license. There are a number of reasons for this, but basically, licensing ensures that the plumber has been well-trained in their craft as well as in local laws and ordinances. With an unlicensed plumber, you have no such assurances.

Additionally, if you hire a licensed plumber and a dispute arises, you can always take action by reporting them to the licensing board. That’s not an option with unlicensed plumbers; in fact, it’s very difficult to hold unlicensed service professionals accountable. As such, seeking a licensed plumber provides an added layer of consumer protection.

Ranking the Top Plumbing Companies in Bargersville, Indiana

Before we unveil our listing of the 10 best local plumbers, here are just a few of the factors we took into consideration as we made our list.

  • Years of experience in the Bargersville area
  • Valid, up-to-date license in Indiana
  • Loads of online reviews, particularly on Facebook, Google, and Yelp
  • An average review rating of 3.0 or higher
  • Accreditation with the local BBB
  • Membership in local trade organizations such as the Chamber of Commerce
  • No known lawsuits or complaints tied with the license
  • An overall excellent reputation in the community

Based on those ranking factors, we now present our picks for Bargersville’s top plumbing companies.

Top 10 Bargersville Plumbers

1) Carter's My Plumber

Among all of the plumbing companies operating in Bargersville, the one we recommend most highly is Carter’s My Plumber. There are plenty of reasons why, starting with the fact that this is a true family business; right now, multiple generations of the Carter family are standing ready to do a great job on your water heater repair or garbage disposal replacement project.

The company has been serving Bargersville and the greater Indianapolis community for decades, and in that time they have developed a reputation for excellent service, upfront pricing, and fast response times. In fact, the Carter team is typically able to provide same-day service.

There’s much to explore on the Carter’s website, including their license number as well as coupons and discounts. Additionally, you can find out more about their work with sump pumps and a host of other common plumbing issues.

This is a company with a sterling reputation, something you can see from their treasure trove of five-star reviews. We feel very confident in recommending Carter’s My Plumber; learn more about this amazing plumbing company, proudly serving homeowners in Bargersville, Indiana.

2) CMP Plumbing

Second on our list is CMP Plumbing, a business with more than 25 years serving homeowners throughout the area. CMP Plumbing has a 24/7 emergency line, and they also supply services in residential, commercial, and new construction plumbing. Their expertise is fairly exhaustive, and their reviews are pretty solid across the board.

If you go to their website, you can find not only their license number, but also information on their BBB membership. (Right now, they have an A+ rating.) To find out more about CMP Plumbing, head over to their website.

3) Estes Full Service Plumbing

Estes Full Service Plumbing is another company that boasts a wealth of experience serving local homeowners. They’ve been around for decades, and in that time they have developed a reputation for professionalism and for friendly service. We will also note that this is a family business, and that they are proudly family-owned and operated.

Estes Full Service Plumbing lives up to its name, helping homeowners address a range of issues. Whether you need a new water heater or you have a water leak you need dealt with, this is a great company to choose. Get more details at their website.

4) Best Greenwood Plumbing

Though technically based in nearby Greenwood, this company is more than happy to help homeowners in the Bargersville community. We’re happy to recommend them, and for a number of reasons. For one, they provide free estimates over the phone. They can furnish a full spectrum of plumbing solutions, and they are known for always doing a great job. Their online reviews attest to a company that’s committed to first-rate service, and the best way to confirm that is to give them a call. Otherwise, check out their website for some additional information.

5) Full Scale Plumbing

Full Scale Plumbing delivers hands-on plumbing expertise to homeowners throughout the greater Indianapolis region, and that certainly includes folks in Bargersville. This is another company that provides free estimates over the phone, and they can tackle any project, no matter how big or how small. And once again, the reviews are excellent, speaking to Full Scale as one of the top plumbers in the area. We highly recommend keeping them in mind for your next home plumbing project. To get more information about them, head over to the Full Scale Plumbing website at any time.

6) Summers Plumbing Heating & Cooling

Need a local business that can assist not just with plumbing and gas leaks, but also with HVAC and furnace needs? Summers does it all, and they do so with superlative service and transparent pricing. They make it easy to save money, too, offering regular discounts and specials on their website. Additional selling points include a responsive emergency line, more than 40 years of experience, and a reputation for high-quality workmanship. To find out more about Summers, we recommend heading over to their business website.

7) Johnson Heating, Cooling, Plumbing

Speaking of companies that do it all, here’s another plumbing and HVAC repair company to have on your radar. The Johnson team is known for their fast, responsive service, including around-the-clock emergency availability. They have been family-owned since 1968, and in that time they have built a stellar reputation within the community. They offer a lot of different services, and have a team of well-qualified technicians. There’s a lot to love about this company, and we are pleased to include them on our list. To find out more about Johnson Heating, Cooling, Plumbing, head over to their website.

8) Winters Plumbing

There are a number of reasons to consider Winters Plumbing. The company has been in business for more than 20 years. They are proudly family-owned, with deep roots in the Bargersville area. They offer a full scope of services, including emergency calls. And, their online reviews are truly phenomenal, attesting to high standards of customer service. Ready to learn more about Winters Plumbing? Head over to their website to gather more information.

9) KJ Plumbing

Based in Indianapolis, KJ Plumbing also provides extensive services to homeowners who live in Bargersville. They are a family-owned business with deep roots in the community, and they are happy to furnish free estimates. If you’re ready to learn more, visit their website.

10) 3 Kings Plumbing

Finally, we would recommend you check out 3 Kings Plumbing. This business is relatively new, but they offer an extensive list of services and have already developed a great reputation. You can visit their website to get more details, including their license number!

Finding a Great Local Plumber: FAQ

Still have some questions about hiring a plumbing company in Bargersville, Indiana? Here are a few answers to common inquiries.

Can plumbers help fix home appliances?

Most plumbers are more than ready to diagnose and address leaks that pertain to your dishwasher, fridge, or garbage disposal. For more complex appliance issues, we recommend seeking a qualified appliance repair business.

Do most plumbing companies put their employees through criminal background checks?

Absolutely, but that’s not something you have to take for granted. Ask directly when you contact them to schedule a service call.

I loved working with my plumber! How can I help them grow their business?

Leaving them a positive review on Google, Facebook, or Yelp can really go a long way. Also don’t forget to recommend them to friends and family.

Where can I find a directory of licensed plumbers who serve homeowners in my area?

We’re glad you asked! Feel free to take a look at our list.

I am a licensed plumber, and wish to be included in the directory. What's the first step?

Learn more about what it takes to get the marks!

Find a Skilled Plumber in Bargersville, Indiana

As you seek the best plumber to meet your home repair needs, we hope you’ll find our recommendations and our general tips to be useful. Remember to double-check that any plumber you hire is licensed. Take a look at online reviews. Ask about free estimates. And if you don’t like the customer service you receive, take your business elsewhere!

Promote the fact that you are licensed